As she becomes ill, they all rally to help her. Fitzgerald is assisted by Edward E. Otto faces a similar struggle over how to express his love. When a German officer proposes a toast in honor of all those who have died in the war—German, British, French, American, and Italian alike—the three young men are clearly in accord with his feelings. Taylor, Young and Tone are equally convincing as best friends and genuinely appear to enjoy each others company. Borzage's sensitive direction, the elegant cinematography of Joseph Ruttenberg The Philadelphia Story, Gaslight, Gigi , and the unobtrusively fluid editing all contribute to the strength of the movie. Even though in retrospect it's easy to see implicit criticism of Nazi Germany and the post-World War I attitudes which brought the Nazis to power, this criticism is so generic that there is no denying that the movie sidesteps crucial political issues.
Tone, as the most intelligent of the three, has never been better—by turns relaxed and intense, and although clearly in love with Patricia himself, deferential to her stronger feelings for Erich. She lost the Oscar to Bette Davis for Jezebel. There are times that the studio sets and process shots driving in car are very artificial looking, but that is expected from the late 1930's. It also becomes a way to express the unity and fraternity of the group. Three war buddies from the German military—Erich Robert Taylor , Otto Franchot Tone , and Gottfried Robert Young —are celebrating the end of World War I in a tavern and making plans for the future.
Does he give up what he believes in for the love of his friends? Three Comrades illustrates the popular cinematic trends and assumptions of the time. The film never condemns the love of these people, but it never shies away from showing the ramifications of their acts of love and the deep damage it causes to others. Hiss and crackle are intact. The picture doesn't look restored, and the digital transfer is far from seamless. World War I is over, let the living begin.
It all leads up to medical troubles and tearful finales for all the friends. Credit to some of these differences must be given to screenwriters F. And through all that's to come, the men know they will remain Three Comrades. Overall, this film left me with a good feeling about the value of true friends and true love. It's more romantic than political.
Melodrama virtuoso Frank Borzage Seventh Heaven directs. Unscripted, a cough would require a retake! Taylor is perhaps the movie's weakest link; you can just picture how much better James Stewart would have been, but Sullavan is lovely and husky-voiced and small and she earned an Oscar nomination for her performance. The film opens with the fraternal love of three brothers in arms. But she is completely willing to live for the present in the glow of their feelings for each other while she has the chance. Gibbons, who worked for Thomas Edison and designed the Oscar statuette, won Academy Awards for a number of films, including The Merry Widow 1934 , Gaslight 1944 and An American in Paris 1951. Her soft, low voice is just mesmerizing to listen to.
Having lost her money and her health, she has resigned herself with stoical acceptance to a forlorn future. Viewer beware: the film shows no real efforts at restoration. Everyone smokes on screen, including Pat with her lung disease?! However, this is just the beginning, and as the film continues, the film takes a darker turn, echoing strains of , a film set amid the rising threat of Nazism in Austria. Online reviewers have written 6 reviews, giving Three Comrades 1938 an average rating of 78%. In the growing darkness, the three friends are given a glimmer of hope: a woman named Patricia Hollmann Margaret Sullavan.
How does love become a form of complication for these four friends? A car they assemble from a scrap heap wins the admiration of wealthy Breuer Lionel Atwill after they beat him in an informal highway race. Still, the four are able to maintain a camaraderie that cannot be touched by the problems of the time. Borzage uses Taylor's pretty-boy blandness to good effect, making obvious the appeal of his hopeful, boyish personality to the world-weary Patricia. Together the three men form a sort of trine of the masculine personality: emotions, action, and intellect. Also, a brief passage for a shot of moon and clouds suggests the opening of his score for Rebecca. Sullavan was nominated for the. Although events of the time are never neglected, it is plainly the personal element of the story that most interests Borzage—the emotional effects of outside events on these four people and the way they are unable to avoid the complications to their lives caused by those events.
The romantic, Erich Robert Taylor , the reason, Otto Franchot Tone , and the idealist, Gottfried Robert Young , celebrate the end of World War I, eagerly looking forward to the season of peace that lies ahead. Nevertheless, the black-and-whites appear rich and not faded, and the sound is nice and clear. Based on the novel by Erich Maria Remarque All Quiet on the Western Front , the movie opens on Armistice Day in 1918. Sullavan has such an easy charm about her and never appears to be acting. Searching for a streaming service to buy, rent, download, or watch the Frank Borzage-directed movie via subscription can be a huge pain, so we here at Moviefone want to do the heavy lifting. At the bar, toasting themselves, are the three comrades of the title: Erich Robert Taylor , Otto Franchot Tone and Gottfried Robert Young.
Now, before we get into all the details of how you can watch 'Three Comrades' right now, here are some details about the Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer romance flick. She is aided by Robert Taylor, Robert Young and Franchot Tone who finish out the talented cast. Guy Kibbee, as a restaurateur, seems to be sneaking up on a German accent, but nothing is definite. Wordplay, one-liners and the repetition of lines become more than just a jousting act to awe the audience, but ways to pierce into the hearts and minds of the characters, show their ambitions, ideologies and flaws. His affiliation with the group puts not only his own life at risk, but the lives of his friends. This lyrical adaptation of Erich Maria Remarque's novel is one of F.
You can help Wikipedia by. Even before the coughing is explained, practically from her first appearance, she conveys an underlying melancholy. She was nominated for an Oscar for this performance but lost to Bette Davis for Jezebel. Melodrama virtuoso Frank Borzage Seventh Heaven directs. Archive Collection, it is a real find for those who love the old movies and for those who can obtain a favorite only in this way. A car they assemble from a scrap heap wins the admiration of wealthy Breuer Lionel Atwill after they beat him in an informal highway race.